“Los Olvidados" - Luis Bunuel (1950)


Luis Bunuel (1900-1983) is a unique figure in the history of cinema.  Almost universally admired and widely celebrated in his later years, he was nevertheless often a controversial iconoclast, and his career had many ups and downs along the way [1].  Critics sometimes simplify his rather complicated artistic career by dividing it into three eras [2]:
  • early avant-garde surrealist films (1929-1933) made in France and Spain;
  • more conventional work in the late 1940s and the 1950s mostly in the Mexican film industry;
  • international co-productions of surrealistic satires in the 1960s and 1970s.
Many critics focus on the first and third eras, while viewing the second era, those early days in Mexico, as a less-significant period when Bunuel was struggling with limited budgets and demands to meet conventional box-office tastes.  But it was in this period when he made what to me is his greatest film, Los Olvidados (literally: “The Forgotten Ones”, but released in the US under the title The Young and the Damned, 1950), a film about a gang of juvenile delinquents in Mexico City’s poor districts.  And it was via this film that Bunuel emerged as a great filmmaker on the international stage.

Bunuel evidently knew what he wanted for this production – he shot the film in just eighteen days, with a mixture of professional and non-professional actors conforming to Bunuel’s uncompromising instructions [2].  When Los Olvidados  premiered in Mexico City, however, it was met with full-scale hostility, as audiences felt the film demeaned the entire nation for its grim picture of Mexican youth.  The producer closed the film only three days after its release, and it looked like the film would be a total loss.  Fortunately, though, leading poet Octavio Paz championed the film and helped it secure entry to the 1951 Cannes Film Festival, where it was enthusiastically received, especially by French Surrealists and other intellectuals.  Bunuel won the Best Director award at Cannes, and the film also received the FIPRESCI International Critics' Award.  After that international recognition, Los Olvidados reopened in Mexico City and this time proved to be a hit with the public.  Bunuel at age fifty had suddenly moved from being an esoteric artiste to become an international celebrity.

Despite his growing international reputation, though, it has always been challenging to categorize Bunuel’s style, particularly during his fecund Mexican period, because of the wide-range of his subject matter.  But there nevertheless always seems to be something uniquely “Bunuelian” about his films, even though it is often difficult to specify just what that is.  In the case of Los Olvidados, there were immediate stylistic comparisons with Italian Neorealism [3], particularly Vittorio De Sica’s Shoeshine (1946) (which admittedly may have had some influence on Bunuel – indeed he spent considerable preparation time investigating the conditions in Mexico City reformatories, and he claimed that much of the material in Los Olvidados was based on real cases).  But there are thematic and stylistic aspects of Los Olvidados that significantly distinguish it from the Neorealist films of that period and that make Bunuel’s film stand alone.

One distinguishing feature of Los Olvidados is the wide compass of the film’s focalization.  Focalization in films concerns the general perspective of the information provided to the viewer in a scene.  When a film or story focalizes on one character, it provides the information surrounding that character that could be known by him or her.  Many times a film might focalize on only one character, and the viewer only knows what that character knows in terms of what is going on.  If there is parallel action, then of course there is more than one focalization.  In any case, whenever a film focalizes on a character, it is likely to induce some degree of viewer sympathy for that character.

In Los Olvidados there are many distinct focalizations, and the viewer thus sees things from many angles.  This is different from “zero focalization”, where the viewer is presented with an objective,  “God’s eye” view of what is happening from a more distant perspective.  In the case of Los Olvidados, the specific focalizations on individual characters project the viewer into the perspectival spaces lived by those characters, and we can’t help but momentarily empathize with those conflicting perspectives.  And this is one of the things that makes watching the film a fascinating experience.

There are nine characters in Los Olvidados that are focalized in the story (and thus with whom to some degree we empathize); yet at least seven of these characters are at times engaged in reprehensible actions that quash our sympathies.  Thus the viewer is tossed back and forth on this turbulent emotional landscape.  The nine focalized characters are
  • From the teenage gang of boys:
    • Jaibo, an older miscreant who has just escaped from a juvenile prison
    • Pedro, a younger  boy and disciple of Jaibo
    • Julián, a more responsible boy who is about the same age as Jaibo.
  •  Other youths:
    • "Ojitos" (meaning “Cute Little Eyes"), a younger boy who has been brought to the city and abandoned by his father.
    • Meche, a teenage girl and younger sister of gang member Cacarizo.
  •  Adults:
    • Pedro's Mother, a widow who works all day as a cleaner to support her four children.
    • Don Carmelo, a blind street musician tormented by the gang
    • Julián's father, a hopeless drunkard
    • The principal of a reformatory “farm school”.
The story proceeds rapidly through five acts.

1.  Introducing the landscape
The film opens on a bunch of idle teenage boys playing on a back street and trying to show off to each other. Their leader is Jaibo, who has recently escaped from incarceration.  Jaibo is their mentor in criminality and seductively assures the boys that if they follow him, they will get money.  He arranges for them to rob an elderly blind street musician, Don Carmelo, but his initial plan is foiled.  Afterwards, though, he and his two main disciples, Pedro and Pelon, follow the blind man to a more deserted area, where they mercilessly beat the man, take his money, and destroy his drum that he uses for his livelihood.

Another one of the teenage boys, Julian, has a job and in the evenings tries to shepherd home his perpetually drunk father. When the two of them pass by Julian’s friend Pedro on the street, Pedro, who boastfully claims only morons work for a living, laughs derisively at Julian’s inebriated dad.  Clearly Pedro enjoys playing the tough guy, and he loyally follows his idol, Jaibo.  In the evening when Pedro comes home to eat, though, his mother is sick of his late-night carousing with street punks and kicks him out of the house.

We also see Ojitos, who has been abandoned on a street corner by his father.  Don Carmelo kindly takes him in as a servant.  Later we see gang member Cacarizo’s pretty sister, Meche, who lives with her extended family in crowded, squalid quarters.  It soon becomes clear that she is the object of Jaibo’s despicable ambitions.

So our sympathies at this point are attuned to Meche, Don Carmelo, and Ojitos.

2.  Jaibo’s treachery
Jaibo believes Julian previously informed on him to the police, thereby sending him to prison, and he wants revenge.  He induces Pedro to take him to Julian and then deceitfully smashes Julian from behind and beats him to a bloody pulp.  Later Jaibo and his gang sadistically beat and rob a legless man who can only move about on a dolly. This is just a further display of Jaibo’s depravity.

A short time later, the gang learns that Julian has been found dead, and the police are trying to find the culprit.  Although Pedro had tried to stop Jaibo from beating Julian, his presence implicates him in the murder, and Jaibo warns him about this.

There are also scenes in this segment showing the ignorant beliefs of the people we have recently been drawn to. Don Carmelo dispenses harebrained folk medicine to Meche’s mother, while Ojitos gives Meche a stolen dead-man’s tooth, which he claims will serve as a talisman.

At the end of this act, Pedro sneaks home to his bed and has a surrealistic dream that is justly famous and has been the subject of much analysis.  In the dream Pedro looks under his bed and is shocked to see the blood-stained body of Julian.  Then his mother rises from her bed and approaches him with the loving tenderness that he has longed for.  When he asks her in the dream for some meat and she gives him some, it is Jaibo this time who rises from under the bed and seizes the offered meat from his hands.  The images of Pedro’s love for his mother and dread of his bête noire Jaibo (who he may fear represents his own demonic side) bring us inside Pedro's disturbed consciousness.

3. Jaibo and Pedro hiding out.
Both JaIbo and Pedro are separately trying to steer clear of police inquiries about Julian’s death.  Pedro, trying to become the boy his mother wants, gets a job as a blacksmith’s apprentice. His mother is unresponsive, though, and his plans are ruined when Jaibo comes to visit him while the blacksmith is out and steals a valuable knife, the crime for which is blamed on Pedro.  Later Jaibo comes to Pedro’s home while Pedro is out and manages to seduce his mother into having sex with him.

4.  Pedro’s struggles
Pedro is still seeking his mother’s love, and comes home to wash himself.  But his unforgiving mother tells him to get lost, and then she beats him.  Pedro then dejectedly tells his mother that she can do what she wants with him, and she turns him into the police.  Wrongly convicted of stealing the blacksmith’s knife, Pedro is sentenced to a reformatory “farm school”.  His mother had told the police she didn’t care if her son was imprisoned, but in a final meeting at the police station, she comes around at last to believing in her son’s innocence.

While at the prison farm, Pedro becomes even more depressed and after getting into a fight with some of the other boys, throws a fit and cruelly beats two farm hens to death.  Seeking to halt the endless rounds of anger and violence, the farm school principal tries a kinder approach and says he freely trusts Pedro with 50 pesos to go outside the farm and purchase some cigarettes for him. Pedro is delighted to receive some unexpected kindness from an authoritative figure and rushes hopefully out the gate.

5.  The last payoffs
Once outside the prison farm grounds, Pedro runs into Jaibo, who immediately steals the 50 pesos.  This later leads to a brutal fight between Pedro and Jaibo, after which Pedro publicly accuses Jaibo of murdering Julian.  This is overheard by the blind street musician Don Carmelo, who ultimately informs the police.

Later Pedro finds out where Jaibo secretly sleeps (which is in a loft in back of Meche’s home) and goes there with a knife to demand the 50 pesos.  However, Jaibo gets the better of him and kills him.  Jaibo runs away, but the police track him down thanks to Don Carmelo’s information and gun down Jaibo. In a second and even more memorable surrealistic scene, Jaibo is shown swooning as he lies dying, thinking to himself:
“You’ve been fixed, ‘Jaibo’.  Right in the head. Watch out, here’s the mangy dog. Look, he’s coming. That’s it, I’m falling into the black hole. I’m alone. Alone.  As always, boy, as always.  Stop thinking. Sleep, boy. Sleep.”
In the final scene Meche and her grandfather discover Pedro’s body, and fearful of police meddling, decide to dump the corpse on a desolate garbage heap.  On the way there, they unknowingly pass Pedro’s mother, who is out looking to bring her lost son home.


There is no simple moral tale to Los Olvidados.  Some people would say that only Pedro was redeemable, but he missed out – all the others were already ruined by the debased circumstances in which they lived.  From my perspective, though, they were all basically redeemable in this narrative; only I don’t think redemption was the issue with Bunuel.  To me it was compassion, and Bunuel elicited in me compassion for all the suffering characters in this story. None of these characters is clearly virtuous, and none is beyond our sympathy, either.  In fact many of the focalized characters show themselves to be capable of hate-filled acts:
  • Pedro abuses the blind and legless, kills the two hens, and comes to threaten Jaibo with a knife.
  • Pedro’s mother is often heartless to her son and, almost until the end, rejects his love.
  • Julian’s drunken father runs out onto the street with a knife threatening murderous revenge.
  • Ojitos at one point threatens to smash the blind Don Carmelo with a heavy stone.
  • Meche, fearful of Don Carmelo taking sexual advantage of her on another occasion, is ready to knife the blind man – with the onlooking Ojitos’s enthusiastic encouragement.
  • Don Carmelo is abused, but he is also a miserly and hateful person who wishes all the young delinquents  to be killed.
And yet the viewer is made to sometimes empathize with these same disparate characters.  Pedro wants love and wants to be good. Even the selfish and deceitful Jaibo is understandable in a way, and the viewer is cast into his existential despair during Jaibo’s surrealistic death sequence.  He is not just a bully. He, like the rest of us, was just struggling to be, to escape, to be free.  Thus Bunuel’s depiction of life in Los Olvidados is deeper and more mysterious than the usual fare.  Andre Bazin recognized this immediately when he first saw the film, pointing out that in Los Olvidados Bunuel avoided typical psychology and morality and confronted existential issues about love and life [4].

In fact Bunuel’s mise-en-scene in Los Olvidados is neither intellectual nor aesthetically artistic – it is ultimately intuitive and visceral. (For just one example, his curious fixation with images of chickens and roosters may suggest many things, such as mindless agitation, but there is something disturbing about them that goes beyond our rational explanation.)

Bunuel, himself, admitted to this tendency of his [5]:
"I have observed things that moved me, which I wanted to transfer to the screen - but, always, with the kind of love I bear for the instinctive and irrational. I've always been attracted by the unknown or strange side of things, which fascinates me without me knowing why."
★★★★

Notes:
  1.  “Luis Bunuel”, Wikipedia, (15 June 2016). 
  2. Charles Ramírez Berg, “Los Olvidados”, Austin Film Society, (n.d.).
  3. The Film Sufi, “Aesthetics of Two Neorealist Films: Open City and Paisan”, The Film Sufi, (18 November 2008)..
  4. André Bazin, “Cruelty and love in Los Olvidados”, What Is Cinema? (Vol.3) - originally 'Los Olvidados', L’Esprit, XX, n. 186 (1951 or 1952), pp. 85-89. 
  5. Andre Bazin and Jacques Doniol-Valcroze, "Conversation with Buñuel", Sight and Sound, 24, no. 4 (Spring 1955), p. 183.  – cited in Radu A. Davidescu, “Themes of Subversion in Luis Buñuel's Los Olvidados and Subida al Cielo”, Collected Essays, (11 June 2009).

“Strangers on a Train” - Alfred Hitchcock (1951)


Strangers on a Train (1951) was something of a showpiece for Alfred Hitchcock, for it gave him the opportunity to present a range of dazzling cinematic artifice in a single film.  Based on Patricia Highsmith’s first novel (Strangers on a Train, 1950), Hitchcock took Highsmith’s kinkiness and added his own extensions to create an utterly perverse masterpiece. 

The story concerns the scheme for a “perfect murder” that is devised by one of two men who happen to meet for the first time by chance on a railway train.  The idea is that since the two men don’t know each other, they have no connection with each other’s lives.  Therefore if perchance they each wanted to murder someone in their own circle, they could perform an exchange – each one, without any hint of motivation, would murder the target in the other’s life.  In each case the one who wanted the victim to die would have an alibi and could prove he had nothing to do with it.

This is the kind of tricky plot device typical of Highsmith, whose tales, which often featured a cynically manipulative and amoral principal character, were made over the succeeding years into a number of popular films [1].  Strangers on a Train, though, is perhaps the most memorable one, even though at the time of the film’s release, the critical reaction was mixed. 

One aspect of the film that has dominated critical reflection over the years (and has probably contributed to the film’s ceaseless popularity) is the underlying homoerotic connection between the two principal characters, i.e. the strangers who meet on the train.  There is no doubt that there is a gay subtext present in the two men’s relationship, but I think this issue should not overshadow the basic elements of the story.  I agree with film scholar Mervyn Nicholson that the more general aspect of male competitiveness, not just gay attraction, is the real psychologically driving force in the story, and this is something that everyone can relate to [2].

As mentioned, there are a number of interesting and memorable cinematic set pieces in the film, and I will mention a few of them in my description.  The story has five basic segments, two of which are basically set pieces on their own.

1.  A Bizarre Proposal
The first set piece shows just the lower shoe-clad legs of two men who men who are boarding a long-distance train.  They are shown separately in an extended sequence of relatively close shots and moving across the screen in opposing directions.  Clearly the two men are fated to meet in this story.  And meet they do when one of the shoes accidentally bumps into its opposing number while they are sitting in the train’s dining car.  One of the men, Bruno Anthony (played by Robert Walker), recognizes the other, Guy Haines (Farley Granger), to be a famous tennis player and strikes up a conversation.  It seems that Guy is not only famous as a tennis player but has also been featured in the gossip columns, and Bruno knows all about it.  Guy is known to be seeking a divorce from his wife so that he can marry his current love, Anne Morton (Ruth Roman), who happens to be the daughter of a US senator.

In the course of insinuating himself into a more intimate discussion with Guy, Bruno invites Guy to his private compartment and expresses his sympathies with Guy’s plight.  Then, in a half-humorous way, he brings up his “perfect murder” scheme. Everyone, he claims, wants to murder someone, but balks at doing so because of the likelihood of getting caught.  For example, he goes on, Guy would want to murder his wife, while Bruno himself wants to murder his wealthy father.  So he suggests that they swap targets: he will murder Guy’s wife and Guy will murder Bruno’s father.  There will be no evident motive for either murder, and they will get away with it.

Guy dismisses Bruno’s ideas as laughably crazy and then gets off the train at Metcalf, New Jersey, to meet with his wife about his divorce plans.  But he forgets his cigarette lighter when he departs, and Bruno pockets it.

In Metcalf Guy visits his estranged wife Miriam (Laura Elliott) and is disturbed to learn that, even though she is clearly promiscuous and carrying another man’s baby, she refuses to agree to a divorce.  In a subsequent phone call to his girlfriend Anne Morton (Ruth Roman), Guy expresses his frustration and tells her that he felt like strangling Miriam.  Hitchcock has shown Miriam in such an unsympathetic light that the viewer feels she really is contemptible (actually, she is just a hedonist).

There are also some scenes showing just how weird Bruno is, and indeed the focalization of the entire film will switch back and forth between Guy and Bruno, contrasting their personalities.  Guy is a modest, straight-shooting gentleman who amiably responds to what he encounters.   Bruno is an effeminate mama’s boy who is emotionally hyped-up and pushy.  Guy is a hardworking achiever who plays by the rules.  Bruno is a spoiled rich man’s son who has accomplished nothing on his own in life. Little by little we see, in fact, that Bruno is a full-blown psychopath.

In another set piece sequence, Bruno takes a train to Metcalf and finds Miriam’s address so that he can stalk her.  In the evening he follows her and her two male admirers to an amusement park, where she  joyfully wanders from one attraction to another, including a rollicking ride on the merry-go-round.  (This amusement park setting establishes the key tenor of the film, as I will comment on below.)  Eventually after a “tunnel of love” boat ride takes her to a darkened area, the pursuing Bruno comes up and quickly strangles her.  Then he slips away without anyone suspecting.

2.  Stalking Guy
When Guy returns to his home in Washington, D.C., he finds Bruno lurking outside.  Bruno tells him that he has killed Guy’s target and now it is Guy’s turn to live up to his end of the “bargain”: he is to kill Bruno’s father.  Guy shows no sign of sadness of Miriam’s death, but only horror at what Bruno has gotten him into.  What Guy had dismissed as a joke turned out to be a horrifying reality.  He tells Bruno to stay away from him.

Because of the gossip columns discussing Guy’s marital problems and the fact that he has no verifiable alibi for the time of the murder, he is immediately a police suspect, and police are assigned to trail his every move. Even Anne suspects Guy, since he had told her that he felt like strangling Miriam. The rest of this segment depicts mounting paranoia, with Bruno persistently following Guy around town and insisting that he go ahead with the second murder.  Even during Guy’s tennis matches, he looks into the crowd to see Bruno’s persistent fixed stare upon him.

There is a memorable party scene in this segment at the home of Senator Morton (Anne’s father), where Bruno shows up and begins making his over-the-top social gestures of conviviality.  At one point he charms some elderly women with his cordial and cheeky talk about how easy it is to murder someone.  With his hands playfully around a woman’s throat he happens to see Anne’s younger sister (impishly played by Hitchcock’s daughter Patricia), whose thick eyeglasses remind him of Miriam and throw him into a psychic fit.  He almost strangles the elderly woman before passing out.  Seeing this, Anne starts putting two and two together and suspects that it was Bruno who killed Miriam.  Guy, of course, knows this, but has no feelings for revenge.  He just wants to get this pestering psychopath off his back.

The next two segments are essentially self-contained set pieces that tantalize the viewer and heighten the suspense but basically delay progress towards the denouement.

3.  The Red Herring
In this segment Guy phones Bruno and tells him he is going to go ahead with Bruno’s desired second murder that evening.  He takes the gun and the house key that Bruno had sent him, sneaks away from his police guards, and makes it to Bruno’s mansion.  The viewer can only be shocked by Guy’s decision, but Guy gives every indication of going through with the job of killing Bruno’s father.

When Guy makes it to the father’s room and sees someone in the bed, he says he has come to warn the father about Bruno’s psychotic condition, not to kill him.  So the viewer has been tricked into falsely assuming that Guy had joined the murder plot, and in fact this whole scene is basically a red herring to spice up the plot.  The person under the covers in the bed, though, turns out to be Bruno, not the father.  The two of them get into an argument, and before leaving, Guy informs Bruno that he will never carry out the second murder.

Later Anne visits Bruno’s house to warn Bruno’s mother about her son.  The mother, however, dismisses Anne’s concerns and mindlessly refuses to consider any negative ideas about her son.  Before leaving, Anne is met by Bruno, who tells her that Guy did kill Miriam and had subsequently asked him to go fetch his cigarette lighter that he had left at the amusement park grounds.

4.  The Tense Buildup
Now it is clear to Anne and Guy that Bruno is going to plant Guy’s cigarette lighter at the Metcalf fairgrounds in order to incriminate Guy.  Guy needs to head Bruno off before the police see the “evidence”. This sets the stage for the next set piece, which depicts the obstacle-strewn race between Guy and Bruno to get to the grounds, which is shown by Hitchcock in a classically tense sequence of parallel action (this is almost a textbook sequence for novice filmmakers to study).

In order to elude his police tails, Guy first must quickly complete a tournament tennis match and then sneak away to Metcalf after the match.  At the same time Bruno is also headed to Metcalf to plant the lighter.  Each of them must deal with unexpected delays, and Hitchcock uses these to play up the tension.  Guy’s tennis match turns out to take longer than he hoped; while Bruno accidentally drops the cigarette lighter down a sewer drain and struggles mightily to retrieve it.  For   eight minutes of screen time, the camera switches rapidly back and forth between Bruno and Guy trying to get past these frustrating obstructions.

Bruno eventually gets to the amusement park first, but he has to wait for the sun to set in order to plant the cigarette lighter surreptitiously.

5.  Finale on the Merry-Go-Round
At sunset, everyone converges on the amusement park: Guy, Bruno, and the police.  When Bruno sees Guy, he jumps onto the turning merry-go-round with Guy in hot pursuit.  The trigger-happy police fire at Guy but kill the merry-go-round operator instead, causing the merry-go-round to start rapidly spinning out of control.  On the wildly whirling carousel, Bruno and Guy get into a deadly fistfight over the lighter before the carousel finally crashes to a halt.  Bruno is mortally wounded, but even with his dying words he still accuses Guy of the murder.  As Bruno dies, though, the lighter drops from his hand, and Guy’s innocence is revealed.


Strangers on a Train is a real horror film, a horror film about how madness can invade an ordinary person’s life.  Hitchcock took Highsmith’s novel about a wickedly clever crime scheme and turned the film into more of a nightmare that is conveyed by the expressionistic effects of lighting, camera work, editing, and diegetic music. 

In fact the camera work of cinematographer Robert Burks won the film’s only Oscar.  The music was also effective, but it was not Dimitri Tiomkin’s customarily intrusive score that I liked but the diegetically-based organ music from the amusement park’s merry-go-round.  This was a mechanical rendition of traditionally upbeat songs, “The Band Played On”, “Carolina in the Morning”, “Oh, You Beautiful Doll”, and “Baby Face”, and we hear the music played to eerie effect in both Acts 1 and 5. In Act 1 Miriam and her boyfriends joyfully sing “The Band Played On” while riding the merry-go-round prior to Miriam’s murder.  In the final act that same song becomes another death signal for the climactic finish.  It is my understanding that this organ music was Hitchcock’s idea, not Tiomkin’s [3].


The acting is also appropriately melodramatic, particularly the oily and disturbingly invasive performance of Robert Walker as the lunatic Bruno Anthony. Unfortunately, Walker had his own mental problems and had received treatment for a psychiatric disorder at the Menninger Clinic in 1949.  Shortly after completing the filming of Strangers on a Train, Walker was forcibly injected with amobarbital medication by his psychiatrist, whereupon he quickly lost consciousness, stopped breathing, and died at the age of 32.

It is interesting to compare Strangers on a Train with another film based on a Patricia Highsmith novel, The American Friend (1977).  Both films are expressionistic and detail the meddling schemes of unconscionable psychopaths entangling innocent men that they encounter.  The American Friend, though, offers a more empathetic view of Jonathon (the psychopath’s innocent target) and his experiences. The viewer is more likely to get inside Jonathon’s head and feel his anxieties as he or she watches the film. As such the film has an existentialist aspect to it. 

Strangers on a Train, on the other hand, is more directly a horror show.  This is where the amusement park metaphor comes into play.  It as if the entire world presented in this film takes place inside an amusement park’s “house of horrors”, and we are the helpless witnesses.  It is not so much that we identify and empathize with the "victim", Guy Haines, but more that we are totally cast into a nightmarish reality where almost everything is strangely tilted – and we are just observers to what goes on.  This was Hitchcock’s way and how he told this tale.
★★★★
           
Notes:
  1. Films of Highsmith’s novels made by top directors include René Clément’s Plein Soleil (Purple Noon, 1960), Wim Wenders’s The American Friend (1977), Claude Chabrol’s Le Cri du Hibou (The Cry of the Owl, 1987), and Anthony Minghella’s The Talented Mr. Ripley (1999).
  2. Mervyn Nicholson, “Stranger and Stranger: Hitchcock and Male Envy”, Bright Lights Film Journal, (1 February 2007).
  3. “Strangers on a Train (film)”, Wikipedia, (11 June 2016).

“The American Friend” - Wim Wenders (1977)


The American Friend (Der Amerikanische Freund, 1977), one of the greatest of all films noir, came not from the US and French film-noir traditions with which we usually associate the genre, but from an upstart young German writer-director, Wim Wenders. Of course when you think about it, the film-noir tradition provides a cinematic vehicle for expressionistic representations of doomed, hopeless existence.  And who better to push the boundaries of this artistic mode than someone from the German culture, with its great heritage of German Expressionism [1]?

Wenders was only 31 at the time of this production, but he had already established himself with a string of films including The Goalie's Anxiety at the Penalty Kick (Die Angst des Tormanns beim Elfmeter, 1972),  and his celebrated Road Movie trilogy – Alice in the Cities (Alice in den Städten, 1974 ), The Wrong Move (Falsche Bewegung, 1975), and Kings of the Road (Im Lauf der Zeit, 1976).  In contrast to those earlier films,  all of which had loosely constructed plots depicting the aimless wanderings of their youthful protagonists, The American Friend moved squarely into the dark, dramatic intensity of the film noir.

The story is based on the work of American crime novelist Patricia Highsmith, primarily Ripley’s Game (1974), but also elements of Ripley Underground (1970).  Highsmith’s provocative thrillers were adopted many times over the years by top filmmakers, including Alfred Hitchcock’s Strangers on a Train (1951), René Clément’s Plein Soleil (Purple Noon, 1960), Claude Chabrol’s  Le Cri du Hibou (The Cry of the Owl, 1987), and Anthony Minghella’s The Talented Mr. Ripley (1999); and many of these stories feature Highsmith’s unconscionable psychopath Tom Ripley as a central character. It was Wenders’s genius, however, to shift more of the focus in The American Friend over to the other principal character in the story, and that is part of what elevates his version of the tale to another level.

In this story there are several dramatic elements that heighten the tension and fascinate the viewer.  First of all there is the psychological contrast between the two principal characters [2].
  • Tom Ripley is a wealthy American “cowboy” (in fact he usually dons a cowboy hat) businessman living in  Hamburg, Germany.  He comes across initially as cordial, but he is utterly ruthless when he feels the need.  Although he is emotionally volatile and reckless, he is also sensitive to others around him and is often insecure on the personal level.  In general he seems to be desperately searching for something that he doesn’t understand.
     
  • Jonathan Zimmerman is a skilled artisan picture framer who operates his own modest shop in Hamburg.  He is a pensive and sensitive perceiver who listens to those around him and doesn’t push himself on others.  He, too, is desperate, but the source of his ultimate anxiety is clearly and constantly in focus: his imminent death from a fatally progressive health condition.
Ripley is the unscrupulous provocateur, and it his “game” to draw the essentially decent and caring Zimmerman into his dark underworld.

Secondly, remember that film noir has three essential narrative obsessions: fatalism, truth, and loyalty [3,4].  In The American Friend each of these aspects is pushed to the extreme end of the scale:

  • Fatalism
    Usually the main film-noir characters have pasts they would like to forget and have no higher hopes than to escape their currently desperate circumstances.  But here the protagonist Zimmerman is faced with what seems to be utterly certain annihilation – there is no escape.
     
  • Truth
    The truth is always elusive in a film noir, with many double-crossers ready to trick you along the way.  Here in this film, untruths are incessant and almost the norm.  Even the basically honest and well-meaning Zimmerman finds himself lying to those around him.
     
  • Loyalty  
    Because almost noone in a film noir can be trusted, including the cops, there is an emphasis on profound loyalty to a trusted individual.  In The American Friend, a mysterious sense of loyalty drives individuals to what can only be considered to be bizarre actions of support.
Thirdly, there is the dramatic element of situating pivotal narrative elements on a train.  There is something mysteriously compelling about such train films.  The cramped feeling of confinement, the limited escape paths, and the strange awareness of a rapidly approaching destiny are all part of this. They all heighten the existential tension of the story.  For a stunning example see Europa (1991). Hitchcock, in particular, exploited these effects in a number of his films, for example The 39 Steps (1935), The Lady Vanishes (1938), Strangers on a Train (1951), and North by Northwest (1959).

All of this dramatic tension is further amplified by Wenders’s expressionistic mise-en-scene, involving the camera work of Robby Müller and editing of Peter Przygodda, both regulars on Wenders films. They employed a considerable number of emotive closeup shots that are smoothly woven into the visual flow of images. These closeups are crucial to the presentation of the byplay of Ripley and Zimmerman and their respective emotional journeys. Equally, if not more, important is the dramatic musical score by Jürgen Knieper, which overlays the film with a feeling of existential alarm.

One further interesting element in the production was Wenders’s filling the cast of dramatic roles with a number of film directors who were variously associated with the film noir tradition.  This included Dennis Hopper, Gérard Blain, Nicholas Ray, Samuel Fuller, Peter Lilienthal, Daniel Schmid, Jean Eustache, and Rudolf Schündler. This will probably fascinate the inveterate cineaste, particularly seeing Nicholas Ray and Sam Fuller, but will not needlessly distract the average viewer.

The story of The American Friend plays out in three international cities – Hamburg, Paris, and New York City – but most of the action takes place in Hamburg.  Although the core narrative constructs are clear, some of the details behind what goes on are a little obscure, and seeing how everything fits together can heighten the enjoyment of a second viewing.  The narrative has four main segments.

1.  Ripley’s Fraudulent Art Game
The film starts in New York with American Tom Ripley (played by Dennis Hopper) talking to  an eccentric artist Derwatt (Nicholas Ray), who apparently fraudulently produces new “originals” of a famous deceased painter [5].  We also see Ripley lounging around his garishly decorated mansion in Hamburg. 

Later at a posh Hamburg art action, Ripley’s confederates bid  up the price of a Derwatt painting on sale before it is purchased by a Canadian friend (David Blue) of a local picture framer, Jonathan Zimmerman (Bruno Ganz), whose wife Marianne (Lisa Kreuzer) works at the auction ceremony.  After the sale, the auction proprietor introduces Jonathan to Ripley, who extends his hand for a shake.  Jonathan somewhat rudely refuses Ripley’s extended hand, saying “I’ve heard of you”, and Ripley quietly fumes.  After Jonathan departs, though, the auction proprietor tries to excuse him by whispering to Ripley that Jonathan is depressed because he is terminally ill from some sort of blood disease.

Later at Ripley’s mansion, he is approached by a French gangster acquaintance,  Raoul Minot (Gérard Blain), who wants to contract Ripley to murder some of his enemies.  Ripley has his limits, though, and tells his friend Minot that he doesn’t like to murder people.

Ripley then visits Zimmerman’s shop to get one of his pictures framed, and the picture framer grudgingly apologizes for rudely refusing the handshake.   He tells Ripley, not knowing that he is in fact a criminal, that he doesn’t usually like people who treat art merely as a business investment.

Zimmerman then gets a telegram from his Canadian friend expressing sorrow over having heard that Zimmerman’s death is imminent.  Jonathan is alarmed, because although he has a life-threatening illness, he had thought that it had not progressed lately.  He rushes to his doctor, who assures him that his illness has not progressed, as was implied by his friend’s telegram. 

We will later learn that the telegram was faked by Ripley as part of an elaborate revenge for the insult of the spurned handshake.  He also apparently told Minot about Zimmerman’s condition. Minot then approaches Zimmerman and offers him a large sum of money to carry out his gangster killing, which he wants performed by an unknown so that he can avoid gangland retaliation.  Minot tells Zimmerman to fly to Paris, where he will pay for a second medical opinion as long as Zimmerman carries out the murder.

By this time the narrative focus has shifted from Ripley to Zimmerman.  Jonathan feels that he will die very soon and leave his wife and five-year-old son destitute.  He, himself, has no future, but he wants to leave something for them; and getting money to kill a known gangster criminal, as Minot assures him his murder target is, may be the only thing he can do for them. 

2.  A Visit to Paris
We are now closely following Jonathan’s angst, as he visits a medical clinic in Paris and gets results (fraudulently faked by Minot, we will later learn) that his condition is indeed hopeless. In a brilliantly filmed 12-minute sequence with no dialogue, Jonathan then stalks his target in the metro with a gun that Minot has given him.  Jonathan is in a daze of fear and confusion but eventually blunderingly carries out the execution and escapes undetected.

Back in New York, an American mafia chief (Sam Fuller) learns about the killing of one of his  top men in Paris.  Jonathan has momentarily escaped and is relieved, but now he has to lie to his wife about why he went to Paris.

3.  A Train Ride from Munich
Minot now offers Jonathan even more money to carry out a second killing.  This time his target is Minot’s ultimate enemy, the American mafia chief.  Jonathan is instructed to go to Munich and carry out the murder on the return train from there back to Hamburg.  It is at this point that we enter into the deliriously riveting 12-minute train ride sequence.

On the claustrophobic and fast-moving train back to Hamburg, the still-dazed Jonathan blunders again and is about to be killed by the mafia chief’s two bodyguards, when Ripley miraculously appears and dispatches them instead.  In fact Ripley does it without even taking the cigarette out of his mouth. Jonathan is shocked and cannot understand why Ripley was on the train to save him. They make it to Hamburg safely, although the targeted mafia chief has not been killed.

4.  Closure in Hamburg
Back in Hamburg Jonathan thanks Ripley and offers him half of his loot for getting rid of the two gangsters.  But Ripley declines and tells Jonathan to keep the money.  Asked what he really wants, Ripley simply says,
“I would like to be your friend.”  
By this point in the story, Jonathan knows that Ripley fabricated the story about Jonathan’s imminent death, so he asks him,
“Why did you spread this rumor. . . that I am with one foot in the grave?”
Ripley responds that he did it to take revenge on Jonathan for not shaking his hand at the auction.
Jonathan: “Is that all?”

Ripley: “Isn’t that enough?
This is what it is all about for the two men.  For Jonathan it is about existential survival.  For Ripley it is about losing face – which for him was also about existential survival.  But Ripley intervened on Jonathan’s behalf when it came to the second murder, because that was not part of his revenge plan against Jonathan – the second murder operation was Minot’s addition.   Such is the strange sense of loyalty and honor in the film-noir netherworld.

There is still more action to come, however.  Minot comes to Jonathan in Hamburg, reporting that his flat in Paris has been bombed by the mafia and wanting to know what got fouled up on the train operation.  Jonathan confesses to him that Ripley helped him. 

After Minot leaves, Jonathan calls up Ripley and reports that his confession has probably implicated Ripley.  Now things are coming to a head.  The mafia are out to get Minot, who may be in turn out to get Ripley.  And the mafia may be out to get Ripley, too.  They all converge on Ripley’s mansion – the American mafia boss with guards, Minot, even Marianne shows up – where Ripley and Jonathan are waiting for the dramatic denouement. You need to view this great film, yourself, to see how it all comes out.


What makes The American Friend compelling is the moody tone it gives to our vicarious experience of Jonathan’s angst-filled passage.  We are empathic fellow travelers on his bizarre journey that has been concocted by Ripley.  The music, the cinematography, and the editing all contribute to this experience.  Wenders even uses certain colors, not as symbols, but as mood-affecting expressionistic artifacts.  For example, the color red stands out in connection with Marianne and also with Ripley’s bedroom. The combination of all these elements provides a rich demonstration of why film can capture existential feelings that cannot be conjured up just from reading text. 

Jonathan Zimmerman’s struggling being-towards-death is contrasted with Ripley’s needy narcissism.  We follow Jonathan into the maelstrom initiated by Ripley, empathizing with his plight and even understanding (though not approving) how he can stagger into a murder plot.  At the same time we are fascinated by the odd “love” that Ripley feels for Jonathan.  Ripley doesn’t just want to be Jonathan’s friend.  He seems to want something more that is not explained.  (In fact a hint of sexual ambiguity is frequently in the background of Highsmith’s stories.)  All of this adds to the intrigue of the tale. 

In order to convey these psychological states, subtle acting is needed, and Wenders got excellent performances from Bruno Ganz, Dennis Hopper, and Lisa Kreuzer.  In fact even though our main empathic focus is on Jonathan, the focalization of the film is not exclusively on him.  The film sometimes focalizes on Ripley and sometimes on Marianne, too.  But in all cases, the viewer is following the action from the perspective of Jonathan.

At the end of the film, noone has gotten what he or she wanted.  Ripley is abandoned and alone on a desolate beach. He reflectively says to himself, 
“Oh well, we made it, anyway, Jonathon.  Be careful.”
This is the film’s closing irony.
★★★★

Notes:
  1. The Film Sufi, “Expressionism in Film”, The Film Sufi, (28 June 2008).
  2. Francine Prose, “Little Lies and Big Disasters”, Film Essays, The Criterion Collection, (12 January 2016).
  3. The Film Sufi, “Film Noir”, The Film Sufi, (8 November 2008).
  4. The Film Sufi, “Le Cercle Rouge”, The Film Sufi, (26 April 2016).
  5. The thought occurred to me that Derwatt may have faked his own death in order to promote the value of new posthumously discovered works, as in the fashion of The Art of Love (1965).

“The Birds” - Alfred Hitchcock (1963)


The Birds (1963), coming relatively late in Alfred Hitchcock’s illustrious career, was one of his biggest and most memorable hits.  It was the fourth film in a string of expressionistic classics, following Vertigo (1958), North by Northwest (1959), and Psycho (1960), that mark a sustained period of high artistic achievement. Although critics dismissed him as a mere crowd-pleasing showman, Hitchcock’s novel narrative structures in each of those four films were keys to their successes with viewers. 

In particular, The Birds features a curious two-part narrative structure somewhat like Vertigo and Psycho.  Both of those preceding films initially drew negative reviews from the critics because of the way they each presented two almost separate stories back-to-back.  The Birds also features two separate narrative threads, shifting from the first over to the second as the film progresses.  But while the separate stories in Vertigo and Psycho were at least linked by a murder, the linkage between the two narratives in The Birds is obscure and has confounded (and intrigued) critics and viewers alike. To some people there is no significantly meaningful connection between the two narrative threads, while others have proposed a variety of suggestive implicative links.  Whatever the case, The Birds, like its two double-narrative predecessors, was also initially panned by the critics.  Nevertheless, it stands today as one of the all-time great films [1].

The dominant story of The Birds (which is the second narrative thread and dominates the second half of the film) concerns an inexplicable eruption of violent bird attacks on the people of a small coastal village in California, and it is loosely based on Daphne du Maurier’s 1952 short story “The Birds”.  As a consequence, the film is generally placed in the horror genre,

Hitchcock and his screenwriter, Evan Hunter (aka “Ed McBain”), added more, including material for that first narrative, the relationship thread. This enabled them to highlight the almost iconic Hitchcockian narrative elements of (a) a classy beautiful blonde heroine and (b) a mature male lead closely hovered over by his fussy mother.  Usually Hitchcock used big-name stars in these principal roles, but he eschewed that practice this time and daringly cast in the big roles some lesser-known figures, who turned out to fit Hitchcock’s expressionistic intuitions to a T and from whom he got very good performances. 

Naturally, many films have a relationship thread, and it is usually a secondary feature to the main problem-to-be-solved thread, such as in Hitchcock’s The 39 Steps (1935). Sometimes the relationship thread can be elevated to have a delicious involvement in the problem thread, as in Notorious (1946), and of course sometimes the whole film can simply be about a key relationship, such as in a romantic comedy.  However, if the relationship thread is elevated to  high prominence and equal status with the problem thread, the viewer expects some significant connections between the two.  And this quizzical narrative connection is what critics struggle with when watching The Birds.

The story proceeds through four main phases and begins with the first narrative thread, which has all the appearances of a light romantic comedy.

1.  Melanie and Mitch
The film opens in San Francisco, with a beautiful and fashionable blonde, Melanie Daniels (played by Tippi Hedren, an unknown in her film debut) entering a bird shop in order to purchase  a provocative gift (a mynah bird) for a relative. She is clearly chic, cordially self-confident, and accustomed to deferential treatment.  She also likes to spoof people in her elegant way, so when an equally self-confident young man, Mitch Brenner (Rod Taylor), enter the shop looking to buy a pair of lovebirds, she immediately begins sparring with him.  On this occasion she uncharacteristically loses the encounter and is intrigued by the man.  After he leaves the shop without the lovebirds, she tracks his residence down to Bodega Bay, a fishing village two hours north of San Francisco, and she decides to play another prank by buying the lovebirds and delivering them, along with a sarcastic note, to him.  All this puts us in the groove for a romantic comedy.

The next day she drives up to Bodega Bay in her fancy sports car and then hires a boat to make a sneak delivery of the lovebirds into the bay-facing back entry of Mitch's house.  But her delivery of the lovebirds is marred when a seagull swoops down on her while she is in the boat and gives her a minor head injury.  Seeing what happened, Mitch takes her to his home and introduces her to his mother, Lydia (Jessica Tandy), who lives with him. After some more sparring between Mitch and Melanie, he invites her to stay for dinner, and given the long drive back to the city plus an invitation to attend a birthday party the following afternoon for Mitch’s 11-year-old sister, she decides to stay for the night at the home of a local schoolteacher, Annie Hathaway (Suzanne Pleshette), whom she had met earlier when entering Bodega Bay.  All the while Melanie is struggling not to show too much interest in the handsome Mitch, and he is showing equal prideful reserve.

The evening conversation between Melanie and Annie, who turns out to have been a former girlfriend of Mitch, offers an interesting study of feminine contrasts. While the mink-clad blonde Melanie is refined and oh-so upper-class, Annie is an earthy and sultry brunette.  Annie reveals that even after the termination of her affair with Mitch, which she says was caused by Lydia’s possessiveness, she was still so in love with him that she moved to Bodega Bay just to be near him as a friend.  So we have now been introduced to four very different women in Mitch’s orbit:
  • Cathy (Veronica Cartwright) – Mitch’s innocent sister
  • Lydia – fussy and possessive
  • Melanie – an ethereal will-o’-the-wisp
  • Annie – passionate but resigned
2.  The Birds Come
The next day at Cathy’s outdoor birthday party, Melanie and Mitch take a stroll and get to know each other better as they let their guards down.  But the party is interrupted by a mysterious and violent bird attack.  Now, fifty minutes into the film, this is when the bird issue comes to the fore and takes over the film. Later that night at the Brenner’s residence, a different group of birds – sparrows this time instead of seagulls – comes down through the chimney and attacks the family.  Mitch manages to shoo the birds out, and Melanie decides to stay over with them for the night.

The next morning Lydia drives over to a neighboring chicken farm and is alarmed to discover the dead body of the farmer, with its eyes having been gouged out by birds. Meanwhile Melanie and Mitch have been getting on together and their ardent morning kiss suggests they may have consummated their relationship the previous night.  When Lydia comes home and reports what happened at the neighboring farm, she is in a state of shock, and Melanie promises to go to Cathy’s school and see that she gets home alright.

3.  Birds Attack Bodega Bay
It is at this point that we move into the realm of horror.  In one of the all-time great buildup scenes, Melanie waits on a bench outside the schoolhouse while the children are singing a nursery rhyme.  As the singsong lyrics are repeated by the children, we see birds gradually gathering behind Melanie’s back outside the school.  When she turns around, she is alarmed to see a massive armada of crows crowded onto the school’s jungle gym.  She informs Annie inside, and the children are ushered out, but the birds attack them viciously.

After the attack, Melanie makes it to a local diner in town, where the customers engage in an animated discussion about what is happening with the birds.  An amateur ornithologist looks for a scientific explanation, a salesman says birds are a nuisance and should be exterminated, and a drunkard sees it all in apocalyptic terms.  Then a scared mother of two children points at Melanie and says all this trouble began the moment the elegant outsider arrived in town, so she must be a bearer of evil.

After another bird attack, during which Mitch arrives, the two of them go back to the schoolhouse to fetch Cathy.  They do find Cathy, but discover that Annie was slaughtered by the birds in the earlier attack.

4.  The Onslaught
Back at his home, Mitch begins boarding up all the windows to protect the family from the next attack.  They have become aware that the birds seem to attack after regular intervals, and in the meantime they settle down and perch silently.  The next bird attack is another highlight of the film, with an outstanding sequence of dynamic camera angles and tight editing.  Again the family survives, but just barely.

During the following lull, Melanie hears an upstairs rustling while the others are asleep downstairs and goes up into Cathy’s empty bedroom to investigate.  Upon entering the room, she sees that birds have torn a hole through the roof and accumulated there inside the room. They attack her immediately, almost killing her. Mitch just manages to save her, but Melanie is now severely injured and in a state of shock.  With his house now compromised with holes and the birds momentarily in one of their lull periods but gathering in massive force for their next assault, Mitch knows time is running out. There is little chance that he and his three women can survive the next devastating attack.


Hitchcock’s expressionistic mise-en-scene is in its full glory in The Birds and helps make this one of the great films.  I have already mentioned two outstanding sequences – the buildup to the bird attack on Annie’s school and the attack on the Brenner home in Act 4 – but there are many other well-crafted scenes throughout.  In general, the special effects used in connection with presenting the attacking birds are still effective even today and are amazing to see.  And the bright technicolor hues, which can sometimes appear unrealistic in other contexts, work well to enhance the expressionistic feel of the presentation.   Credit must be also given in these respects to cinematographer Robert Burks, (a regular with Hitchcock since Strangers on a Train), and film editor George Tomasini (Hitchcock’s regular editor since Rear Window).

The acting is also generally good and expressionistically appropriate, with Hitchcock’s many closeups of Tippi Hedren highlighting her ethereal beauty. There is one scene, however, that is seriously out of whack with the rest of the show, and that is the discussion about the birds with the townspeople in the local diner. The acting in that scene is seriously overdone and artificial, lowering the film into B-grade histrionics.  Curiously it is this scene that the screenwriter claims was his great achievement in the film [2].

The question of what was behind the bird attacks is still an issue though.  There are several possibilities.

  • The caged lovebirds
    The lovebirds (Hitchcock's "MacGuffin" in this film [3]) that Melanie brought to Mitch Brenner are quiet and utterly docile.  But they seem to have symbolic significance, and their appearance more or less coincides with the bird attacks.  Perhaps the lovebirds trigger an eruption of the bird world’s fury over the way mankind has trapped, killed, and confined innocent birds.  In the last scene when Mitch is ushering Melanie and his family into Melanie’s car for an attempted escape, Cathy says she wants to take the lovebirds along with them.  In these dire circumstances, you can almost hear the viewers imploring Cathy not to do that – that those lovebirds are somehow linked to the bird kingdom’s unquenchable rage.
     
  • Melanie’s unnatural interference with nature
    Melanie is beautiful, but she is artificially coiffed and clad in mink.  Both she and Mitch are used to manipulating the world – almost playing with it – to get what they want out of it.  As such, they are uncooperative extractors, not inclusive contributors, to the world’s life force. Perhaps, then, Melanie is an iconic representative of man’s separation form the natural world, which has induced its wrath.  According to this interpretation, the hysterical mother was more or less correct when she denounced Melanie for bringing on the birds’ rampant attacks.
     
  • Primeval feminine power unleashed 
    Many feminists have criticized Hitchcock over the years for misogyny and having a distorted view of women.  There are, after all, a number of power plays going in the film between Melanie, Lydia, and Annie, and some critics see the film as a display of Hitchcock’s obsession with feminine mystery as some kind of threat. Cultural critic Camille Paglia, who wrote a monograph about The Birds [4], has in this connection commented [5]: 
    “[Hitchcock was] in the main line of the Hollywood view of the divinity and yet ultimately secret malice of woman. . . .

    There is something mysterious about femaleness — coming from the facts of woman’s physical nature, the endless mysteries of the shadowy womb, and the power of  procreation that even she doesn’t understand. Part of what I got from Hitchcock is his vision of woman’s un-knowability, her un-reachability, her enormous beauty — the glamorous artifice with which she cloaks herself but ultimately her incredible, natural sexual power.”
    So from this perspective, the rage of the birds (and hence nature’s rage) may be somehow associated with the mystery of feminine power.
     
  • The mystery of existence and annihilation 
    Going further and more fundamentally, we can observe that there is something ultimately mysterious about what it is that activates the universe. What is the source of this unfathomable animation that drives our consciousness and our experiences? This is an issue that was touched on in Tarkovsky’s Stalker (1979), wherein “the Zone” was a region representing the dynamic vitality of existence, which could be both a promise and a menace but was ultimately unknowable.  Philosopher Galen Strawson has commented lucidly on this topic, for it is an unresolved philosophical issue [6].  In this sense the eruption of the bird kingdom’s rage is essentially a manifestation of nature’s ultimate, savage unpredictability. But it is not mechanical unpredictability, like an explosion or a hurricane; it involves the unpredictability of primordial agency.  We must admit that we have no intellectual grasp of primordial agency. It can embody love or hatred without our understanding.
In my view it is this last scheme that captures what it is that makes The Birds so endlessly fascinating.  The film thus represents the ultimate in existential horror.  It is not just that we might be destroyed, but that nature itself, the primordial prana or qi, might erupt in uncontrollable predatory hatred and annihilate us, humanity. Hitchcock needed the relationship narrative to situate the viewer’s empathy across a range of human caring and feeling among the main characters, so that it could be contrasted with impenetrable, nihilistic hatred. This is not just about lovebirds, or femininity, or a response to human selfishness.  It is about something deeper and more dreadful. It was Hitchcock’s art to be able to capture this consummate horror in film form.
★★★★

Notes:
  1. Roderick Heath, “The Birds (1963)”, Ferdy on Films, (2006).
  2. Christopher Mulrooney, “The Language of The Birds”, Deep South, University of Otago, New Zealand (2007). 
  3. See
  4. Camlle Paglia, The Birds, The British Film Institute, (1998).
  5. Camille Paglia, quoted in
  6. Galen Strawson, “Consciousness Isn’t a Mystery. It’s Matter”, The Stone, International New York Times, (16 May  2016).